1

Re: Synonymy and gall causers

I have made a couple of postings recently querying the way that the dictionary deals with gall causers (Puccinia urticata, Eriophyes galii, perhaps another one somewhere).  Now I find another with a similar apparent fault.

Acalitus longisetosus (Nalepa, 1892)  TaxonVersionKey: NHMSYS0020703336 is a good name, but

Eriophyes longisetosus TaxonVersionKey: NBNSYS0000033013 (a bad name, no authority)

which should be a synonym of Acalitus is returned separately.

The fact that the same problem has turned up in three different gall causers (one rust, two mites) would seem to suggest that all is not well in the relations between synonyms in the relevant checklists, and that the tables should be checked.  It is extremely improbable that I have casually and randomly come on the only examples of what seem to be errors.

If the current situation is correct, I would welcome clarification.  It is not, however, helpful to have synonyms mapped separately when one calls up a map on the Gateway.  In this case the 'good name' returns no map at all, while the bad name shows four dots.

Murdo

2

Re: Synonymy and gall causers

Another example in the same mould - Macrodiplosis roboris (Hardy, 1854)  TaxonVersionKey: NHMSYS0020470382 is, I am assured by Google and other sources, the current name to use for Macrodiplosis volvens Kieffer, 1895 TaxonVersionKey: NBNSYS0000027975.  These are returned separately on the Gateway, though in this case both are good names, apparently.

M.

3

Re: Synonymy and gall causers

... and another one that has appeared by chance on my radar - Aceria thomasi (Nalepa, 1889) TaxonVersionKey: NHMSYS0020190431 and Eriophyes thomasi TaxonVersionKey: NBNSYS0000037055.

I think this establishes what I suggested above, that **there is a serious and widespread problem in the way gall-causers are treated, and in the way synonymies between the BPGS checklist and other checklists are set up**.

I will not report any further cases of this flavour until someone responds to the posts.

M.

4

Re: Synonymy and gall causers

I have updated the 2 Eriophyes - as you say, there are likely to have been a few old lists with the older names on them and they have lain unchecked because there are few mite experts to offer their advice. I didn't update the Macrodiplosis though, just due to lack of any conclusive evidence. Cecidomyid experts are pretty thin on the ground too. ;)

Chris Raper, Manager of the UK Species Inventory, Angela Marmont Centre for UK Biodiversity,
Natural History Museum, Cromwell Road, London, SW7 5BD.  (tel: 020 7942 5894)
also Tachinid Recording Scheme (http://tachinidae.org.uk/)